Leadership is key to an outstanding performing care business, but it’s not often an area that is actively developed at every level within care businesses.
On this week’s #TeaWithTobi we discuss why a leadership culture is so important in your #carehome or #homecare business and give you some practical exercises you can do to start empowering your staff and reaping the benefits of a strong leadership culture.
Find Sophie here:
https://judgementindex.co.uk/
https://www.linkedin.com/in/sophiecoulthard/
Resources mentioned:
The Care Leader’s Handbook – Sophie & Rob Coulthard
Skill Will Matrix
Special thanks to our season sponsor everyLIFE Technologies:
everyLIFE Technologies are creators of the PASSsystem, a digital care planning solution that is proven to improve business efficiency, help you stay compliant, allow you to evidence accountability and provide the best quality care. Visit their website for more information: https://www.everylifetechnologies.com/
Listen to the audio version on your favourite platform:
► Apple Podcasts
► Spotify
Download your free care growth Ebook:
Home Care Ebook
Care Home Ebook
[00:00]
Sophie Coulthard: That's a challenge people could go away and start doing. The next time someone comes to you with something and you think they could figure it out for themselves, refuse to tell, only ask, and see if you can get them to come to the answer themselves. That's how you start to build a leadership culture, and we've seen that flow through a company.
Cameron: Hi, I'm Cameron from Smooth Digital [Smooth Digital, now Prosperwell], and welcome to Tea with Tobi, the show where we ask and answer the questions playing on the minds of care sector business leaders. This week's episode is sponsored by everyLIFE Technologies, and we're going to kick off the show with a few words from our marketing strategy director, Tobi Alli-Usman.
Tobi Alli-Usman: Cameron, thank you for the intro. For those of you who are new to the show, just to give you a bit of background: here at Smooth Digital, our main focus is to help care homes and home care businesses maximise their ability to provide the very best care in their communities, and in order to do that they're going to need to grow. We know care business leaders have a number of challenges when it comes to growth, so we want this to be the place where you can put the kettle on, have some tea and enjoy a growth-focused conversation, and hopefully take away some actionable tips you can implement in your business. On that note, I'd like to invite our guest, Sophie. Hello, thanks for being here. Sophie, before we start, for the benefit of the audience, could you give us a little background about who you are and your area of expertise?
Meet Sophie
Sophie: I'm Sophie Coulthard, and I work for a company called Judgement Index. We work with care companies and support them in all sorts of ways, with their recruitment and retention and with their leadership development as well. My personal background is sales and marketing, really, but I grew up with a dad who was a performance coach, so I was always involved in leadership. In the school holidays I'd be sat at the back of a room somewhere watching him run leadership workshops, and you don't realise how much you absorb. So we now work together. The other thing I do, and probably why anybody would recognise my voice, is I host the Road to Outstanding podcast as well, which is a podcast about sharing best practice, tips and ideas with people in the care sector.
Tobi: So now people can put a face to the voice.
Sophie: Yes.
Tobi: The original queen of podcasts. It's nice to be on this side.
Why a leadership culture matters
[03:00]
Tobi: So, in Tea with Tobi fashion, let's jump into the questions. The first topic I wanted to discuss was culture. That's on everyone's lips. It was Peter Drucker who said culture eats strategy for breakfast, and I agree. I think you can achieve some amazing things with the right culture in a company. The question I have for you is: why should care companies not only have and develop the right culture, but the right leadership culture?
Sophie: It's interesting, because I used that quote in an article I wrote. With culture, I think the first thing to think about is that people quite often just talk about a good culture or a bad culture, but there are all sorts of different types of culture you can have within a company. You could have very much a learning culture, where people are encouraged to learn and develop. You can have a cliquey culture, and you can have the kind of toxic culture we hear about quite often. But I think a leadership culture is a great thing for care companies to strive for. We need more leaders in care. I think we need more leaders in all sorts of industries, but that's a different conversation.
One thing I find is that quite often, if I talk about leadership in front of a room, I'll ask people to put their hands up if they're a leader, and so many people don't put their hands up, even in a room of people who might be team leaders, deputies or even managers. They might think of themselves as a manager, but not a leader. We're all leaders. If you're not the leader of a team, you're at least the leader of yourself. And I think in care, you're often leading the people you care for, at a very basic level.
So if we can start to develop that mindset, how can we encourage our staff and our teams to think like leaders and problem-solve for themselves, and develop a culture where people do think of themselves as a leader in some way, that will start to develop a culture where people are more self-sufficient and can make decisions for themselves. That will help a company thrive, and it will also help the leader, the manager, who is probably quite bogged down with having to tell people what to do all the time. So I think there are lots of benefits to thinking, how can I develop a leadership culture within my home or company?
Building a leadership culture
Tobi: So, someone listening to this today, let's say they head up a company. What can they do to support and encourage leadership in the company?
[06:06]
Sophie: I think there's definitely more that places can do in terms of giving responsibility. There are all sorts of roles people could take on. We see roles such as activities coordinators, but even things like social media. A lot of people are reluctant to give social media to members of staff, and I'm sure it's probably a hot topic for you. But give people that extra bit of responsibility and test the water with them. Give them some safe boundaries to work within. There's all sorts. You could have a little events team of people thinking about how they could run events for a care company, or charity fundraising. There are all sorts of ways you could start to test people and give them a bit of extra responsibility, and that will help them feel valued and hopefully start to bring that side out of them.
Tobi: I know there are probably some listeners who are control freaks. If you allow someone to take on a project, you have to be willing to allow an environment where they might make a mistake. Have you got any examples of companies you've worked with that have taken on a leadership culture project successfully and built on it?
Sophie: I can think of a company we've worked with where they had a lot of very young leaders. They had quite a young workforce, and they really identified that they needed to start thinking about how their team leaders will be their next deputies, and their deputies will be their next managers, and how they could give them some tools to support and develop them so they're ready. We worked with them over a number of months and taught them a lot of things, many of which are in the book, which I'm sure we'll talk about later.
The important thing with people who are control freaks, and I know this because I am one, my staff will tell you, is that it can be very easy, and I've seen this within care homes, time is short. A manager's job has more tasks, processes and admin than ever before, so it's a lot easier to just tell people what to do, especially in a morning meeting, or if somebody comes to you with an issue. The quickest way to get something done is to say do this, do that. But it's not allowing people to think for themselves. One thing we talk about a lot, and always try to instil in everyone we work with, is learning how to coach. A lot of managers say that
[09:05]
they coach, but when I've shadowed managers for the day, I've seen them say, OK, I'm going to coach. Coaching is really all about asking questions, open questions, and believing that the person can find the answer within themselves. If people are listening to this now, I would say think about your team. Do they actually know the answers within themselves? Whether it's confidence, or the lack of a leadership culture within the company stopping them from thinking for themselves, they come to you, they ask the question, and they want you to tell them what to do, because they'll feel safer that way. But start to ask them questions. Don't give them the answer. See if you can tease it out of them. When I've watched managers do this, they start off well, then they get a bit frustrated, and it's a lot easier to tell them. And that's a challenge people could go away and start doing. The next time someone comes to you with something and you think they could figure it out for themselves, refuse to tell, only ask, and see if you can get them to come to the answer themselves. That's how you start to build a leadership culture, and we've seen that flow through a company.
How to empower your staff
Tobi: Excellent. So the next question I have is: how can companies empower their staff? You touched on confidence earlier. What can they be doing to empower their staff?
Sophie: That's an interesting one, because I don't think companies should be empowering every member of staff. If you have a team member who is lacking in motivation, or lacking in skills and knowledge, and you empower that team member to go off and do something, first of all, is it going to get done? And secondly, if they don't have the skills to do it and they fail, that could knock their confidence for next time. So it's about empowering the right people, and then, for the people who aren't ready to be empowered for whatever reason, how do you motivate them, guide them, or get them to a stage where you can empower them? I think empower is such a buzzword, and everybody's thinking, how can we empower our staff? But if it's not used in the right way, it could potentially be a bit dangerous.
I've actually got something here. This is really practical, and I always want to give something practical. I appreciate that if people are listening to this and not watching
[12:01]
it, let's see if I can make this make sense, but I'm sure we can put a link to the Skill Will Matrix in the show notes. For people who are watching, it's a really good little exercise you can go and do, maybe at home with a glass of wine or a tea, or whatever your tipple of choice is. And I would also say, if you're going to do this exercise, be wary that it's about your staff and your team, so you don't want to leave it lying around somewhere where somebody could pick it up.
It's quite simple. You draw a grid box and divide it into four sections on the page, and then you have an axis. This is called a Skill Will Matrix, so anybody can Google Skill Will Matrix and find it online. It wasn't invented by me, but it's a really great tool, and I've used it with my own teams in the past, when I've had sales teams and things like that. People have either a high will or a low will: they're very enthusiastic and motivated, or they really can't be bothered. Then you've got high skill and low skill. You've got your experienced members of staff who know what they're doing and are qualified, or you've got people who aren't skilled for whatever reason. That could be somebody you've taken on who's got no experience in the care sector whatsoever, so they won't have any skill, and that's not necessarily their fault.
Then you think about your immediate team. You might want to do this in teams if you have a big home, or if you've got a small team of, say, six or seven, however you want to do it, and you start to plot them on here. So I'm thinking about a member of my team, and I'm thinking, they're really, really motivated, they're brand new, they're excited to get started, but they don't have any skill at the moment. So I'd have them up here for high will, but low skill, as opposed to if they were highly skilled. Here's one I made earlier, and I've used your names as well, sorry. Tobi: highly skilled, really experienced, really motivated, really high will. He's up in this top right-hand box. I'll show you what the boxes mean in a second, but this is somebody you can empower, and actually it would be damaging if you didn't empower this person. If this person's being told what to do on a daily basis, their motivation is slowly going to dwindle, because they don't feel they can get on with the job. They feel like they're always being told what to do, and that could cause this person to start looking elsewhere: let me go somewhere where I'm valued and appreciated, because I know
[15:04]
what I'm doing, I'm competent and I'm enthusiastic.
And I've talked about this one, high will but low skill. Cameron! This person really needs to be guided. You'd want to upskill this person as quickly as possible. You'd probably want to make this person their mentor, so they can really help them develop, because you want to get them over here as soon as possible, so you can empower them and let them get on with it.
Now, someone down here is going to be a bit of a problem for you: somebody who's really highly skilled, probably someone who's worked for you for a long time, but who has the mentality now where they really can't be bothered. If I ever talk about this, you normally hear chuckles from people, because they know they have someone like this. They can be difficult. Are you going to empower that person? Yes, they're capable of getting the job done, but are they going to do it? And obviously this person down here is the real issue, because if they don't have the skills and they're also not motivated, this person could be damaging to the rest of your team. One bad apple can spoil the crop.
So if you go and have a look at the Skill Will Matrix and plot your staff, these are the different options you have. We probably don't have time to go into all of it, but to give people an idea: the people up here, yes, empower them. The people down here, you're going to have to tell them what to do, and they're probably going to take up all your time. But if you want to really develop a leadership culture, plot your people and start to think, how can I get them up here? What's the best way for me to lead them?
Tobi: That's amazing. So, really obviously: high skill, high will, you empower. Low will, low skill, you direct them.
Sophie: Yes.
Who to attract
Tobi: So a question for you: who should people try to attract? From that grid, I know loads of people are attracting people who have loads of experience, who are probably applying on Indeed for loads of different jobs, job hopping, and they fall into the low will, high skill box.
Sophie: Yes, so you're going to have to try to find some motivation from within them. What attracted them to the sector in the first place, if they've been in the sector for a long time and they're experienced, the job hoppers? What is it about care that brought them into the sector? Most people I speak to have a story of why they joined the sector. But if they're down here, if they've got a really low
[18:02]
will, it's going to be tough. We say in the book, sometimes, are they going to be worth your effort, or is it time to find them gainful employment elsewhere? But I'm hearing a lot of people start to say now, let's find people who are motivated, and we can teach them. Amazing.
Values-based recruitment
Tobi: I see you've got a copy of the book underneath there. I definitely recommend it. I've had a read of it myself, and it's very practical, and we love practicality. One of the subjects in there is recruitment and retention. You've touched on it, and on how some people are now moving to values-based recruitment. Can you talk a little bit about what values-based recruitment is and why it's important for a care business?
Sophie: Yes. I think it's important to point out that the book, The Care Leader's Handbook, is a leadership book, but recruitment and retention do come into it, because that quite often falls under the manager's role as well. Values-based recruitment was made popular by Skills for Care, and they do a lot of work looking at values-based recruitment and how you can attract people with the right values. A bit like what we were just talking about: people who have something that's driven them to come and work in this sector.
The way I talk about it is maybe slightly different, to give people something new to think about. Care company values are often the same. You go from one home to another to another: caring. People watching right now, do you have caring? Do you have respect? Do you have passion? All of these words are overused in that sense, and fair enough, because that is what the sector is about. But I think the problem is, it's all very well having values and trying to attract people who match those values, but they lose their meaning when they're all the same and when they're just words on a wall. I actually walked past a building on my way here that had some words on the wall, be humble, this, that and the other, and I thought, I wonder how many people actually think, oh yes, we live by those values.
That's quite often the issue: values aren't owned by the staff who work there. They've been given to them by a marketing team somewhere up in head office, and they've been told, these are your values. If I came up to you, Cameron, and said, right, you're working here, your values are this, this and this, you might think, they're not mine. They need to be owned
[21:07]
by the team. One way people can do this is to get together with the team and have a little workshop. Get some tea in, get a bit of cake. It can be a relaxed, casual thing. Take your values, whatever they may be, three or four is ideal, not too many, and say, OK, if we took this value of respect, I want you all to have a bit of a brainstorm. Get some coloured paper. What does it mean to you, and what does it mean here?
It's interesting, because I've done this workshop with managers before, and I've had people say to me, well, it means respecting the residents, and that's it, it can't mean anything else. But if you get a team of people together who deliver care and ask them what respect means, they might come out with quite different ideas. Yes, it might include that, but actually, for us as a team, what does it mean? It means we respect each other. We give each other the same respect we would give a resident. And they might go, oh yes, I like that. That means something to us. That's a value we might not live by right now, but it's the value we should live by. You're not changing the word respect, and you don't have to paint over your wall. It's developing it more into what I call a culture statement that the staff can get on board with: yes, let's live by this.
Once you've got that, coming back to values-based recruitment, you can start to think, right, that's what respect means here. So in my job ad, in my social media posts, in my blog and newsletter, we're going to pick that out, and it's not just going to be respect as one of our values. It's going to be: our staff really believe this. This is something we live by, and if you think that too, come and work with us. And somebody might read that and think, actually, I work somewhere at the moment where the staff don't have the same respect for each other, and I want to work somewhere that believes in that. I think that's how you can take your values further. They're not just words on a wall any more. Values-based recruitment doesn't mean much unless you make it mean something.
The Care Leader's Handbook
Tobi: Tell us a little bit more about the book and what made you write it.
Sophie: We run leadership workshops and academies up and down the country for care companies, but not all care companies can afford these types of services. We're very lucky that we work with companies that have the ability and the funds to put on these kinds of workshops for their staff, and we thought, how can we get it out
[24:07]
there to more people? Anybody can pick up a copy of the book and take some of the ideas and the things we teach and put them into practice. It might not be the same as having someone come in and really work with you, but to be able to get it out there and have people read it and say, I'm going to go and try that, that's great. I believe in giving people value and content. As well as that, it makes a great reference for people who have done work with us, because they might be doing a workshop once a month for five or six months, and then they go away and get back on with their lives, and it's something they can refer to. Everything in there, like the Skill Will Matrix I showed you earlier, is in the book, and people can download things from the online resources.
Cameron: Just before your next question, Tobi, let's take a short break, and we'll be back with you very quickly.
Tobi: "We really need private paying clients in our care business, but we don't understand the world of digital marketing. What should we do?" That's a question we get a lot from businesses in the community. So we've put together an ebook called The Care Growth Blueprint, which is a step-by-step guide to the marketing steps you need to put in place to attract private paying clients into your business. Download the ebook, the link should be in the description below, and enjoy the rest of the show.
Common traits of outstanding leaders
Cameron: Hi everyone, welcome back, and we'll start again with some more questions from Tobi.
Tobi: So, a question I'm guessing listeners will be really interested in, and it's actually a subject in the book: what are the common traits you find in outstanding leaders?
Sophie: Really interesting, actually. We were asked to get involved in some research with a chap called [name unclear], who runs a consultancy, so I'll give him a little plug. He was really interested in this: Outstanding tends to be the benchmark, and we know what makes an Outstanding home, and lots has been done on that, but what makes an outstanding manager? What do these managers have in common? Because there's no Outstanding home without an outstanding manager, and I think people would probably agree with that. So is there a way we can look at what these outstanding managers have in common? He ran a survey and captured a lot of information, and then we used the Judgement Index, which is the assessment we use that measures what we call values-based behaviours, and had a look at what was coming out of that research. Obviously we had no idea what was going to come out, or whether it would show us something that might be key, and what was really
[27:06]
interesting is that all of the outstanding managers might have had different personalities from each other, but the traits in their assessment results were so close. They were so strong in how similar they were, and also in their strength in what we call values-based behaviours. To break that down a bit: they were all very fast problem solvers, with the ability to take in information, process it, come up with quality decisions, think on their feet and handle difficult scenarios. All of those things they had in common, really super strong, and the book breaks all of it down. There weren't really any things that were different, where you could say this manager had this and that manager had that.
The key thing I found when I looked at the research is that what they all had in common is what I like to call a solid foundation of themselves. A lot of us can go to work and perform at work, not sing and dance, but get on with the job and do a good job. But internally we might be lacking in confidence. We might be really tough on ourselves and beat ourselves up if things don't go well, with a lot of self-criticism. We might have low self-esteem. We might also have stress in our personal lives. Everybody has things that happen in their lives. What all of these managers had in common was the ability to cope with whatever was going on in their own world, and when people are like that, you tend to get more out of them at work.
So if people listening or watching now think about their team, think about who comes into work, is consistent, does a good job and doesn't cause you any drama. Quite often they'll be the people who are cool in themselves. They don't have any issues, they can handle things. I find it really difficult to explain. I always say they're cool in themselves: calm, self-confident, self-assured, and you get more out of them as a result. The people who will cause you the biggest headache at work will be the people who have all sorts going on, either in their personal lives or as issues under the surface. Obviously people have things that happen, but the fact that these managers all had this kind of foundation meant they could get so much done at work, and that was a really key finding. The book explains it in a lot more detail, and there are some graphics that help break it down.
Getting under the surface at interview
Tobi: It's easier to identify those traits in people
[30:05]
you've worked with, so if you're promoting from within, it's easier to do that. But what about people who are just doing interviews? All they have is 30 minutes or an hour, and these people are, if you like, acting. You can't really see this foundation in that scenario. So what can they do?
Sophie: It's really tricky. If people think about a hire they made where they thought, this person's great, they're saying all the right things, they're great in the interview, and then three months later you think, who was that person I hired? Everyone has a story like that. And especially with people who are job hoppers, who've moved around the care industry, they know what they should be answering.
Tobi: What you want to hear.
Sophie: Yes, exactly. So how do you get under the surface? I think there are some interesting questions you can ask at interview, and it's about getting yourself a bit more comfortable with knowing how to interview, so you can tease out what might be under the surface, because that's probably what will get in the way of them doing a good job. And that's the thing: we give people training in how to do tasks, all this compulsory training, but there's not so much training on how to handle yourself personally, how to cope when you've got a lot of pressure, and it's the people who are good at those things who will do better.
I can do a really good plug for the Judgement Index here. I'm always conscious that it's not always possible for everybody to implement these types of things, but look at a tool like the Judgement Index. We've had thousands of people take this assessment, which measures values-based behaviours, and it allows you to ask questions and probe a bit deeper. We provide interview questions as well, so if somebody has an area where you think, OK, I'm going to ask another question around this, this is telling me they're not coping very well at work right now, why is it that they're not coping? Is it something we can handle if we give them the job, or is it actually not the right person for the job?
Tobi: So let's create a scenario. Let's say you're hiring a manager, and you've got three people who all say the best things, the right things. They each take this assessment, which is a series of questions. What happens once each of the three has taken the assessment?
Sophie: The company would get reports, and we can do this ad hoc as well, by the way.
[33:02]
Sometimes a company will say, we're putting a really important person in post and we need to make sure we get the right person, and that's a great time for people to come to us, because we can support them with that, and it brings it to life for them. We'll say to them, ideally at a second interview or at the first interview, here are some key questions based on their results. Let's say they all come in and they're all great, and maybe you'd otherwise make a decision based on experience or qualifications. Here are some questions to think about. It could be that somebody is really, really task-orientated, and their ability to be really good with people is not as strong. Now, you might want to hire someone who's going to come in and kick some butt. Maybe there have been some issues in the company and you need someone to drive tasks, and then that could mean that person's the right person. But if you've had a tough time and you want somebody who's going to really nurture the staff, you're going to want somebody who's slightly more people-focused, perhaps.
Tobi: I'm looking at the time now, and Cameron's going to stop me. If someone wanted to learn a little bit more, where can they find you?
Sophie: Our website is judgementindex.co.uk, very easy, and there's lots on there about the different work we do with care companies as well. We're not just one thing, we do all sorts really. There are some videos and more information about our leadership academies as well.
Tobi: And what's the best place to pick up the book?
Sophie: The book's on Amazon, so just put The Care Leader's Handbook in, and if you ever see us at a show, we should have some copies there as well.
Cameron: Thank you, Sophie, that was a really great episode again. Any of the resources we've talked about, the book, the matrix and anything else that's been mentioned, will be in the show notes, so you don't have to rewind and go and find it. It'll be there in the description. Thanks again for watching and listening, and we'll see you next week.
Tobi: See you next week.
Podcast Sponsor
everyLIFE Technologies are creators of the PASSsystem, a digital care planning solution that is proven to improve business efficiency, help you stay compliant, allow you to evidence accountability and provide the best quality care.
