The best way to combat the negativity from the national media surrounding care homes during COVID-19 is to promote positive stories.
On this week’s #TeaWithTobi☕️ we are joined by York Woodford-Smith and Adam James to discuss how care homes can use video and local media to reduce the effects of the negative publicity they’ve been receiving over the past couple of months – at no fault of their own.
We discuss they types of stories that will reduce the concerns of families and give local media journalists the positive care home stories they are calling out for!
Find York & Adam here:
York Woodford-Smith LinkedIn
Adam James LinkedIn
Resources mentioned:
York’s video starring Molly
[0:00]
Cameron: Hi, I'm Cameron from Smooth Digital [Smooth Digital, now Prosperwell], and welcome to Tea with Tobi, the show where we ask and answer the questions playing on the minds of the care sector's business leaders. This week's episode is sponsored by The Access Group, and today we're going to be talking about all things video for care homes. So let's kick off the show with a few words from our marketing strategy director, Tobi Alli-Usman.
Tobi Alli-Usman: Thank you, Cameron. I must say there's been a little bit of a glitch today, so apologies to everybody for that. Like Cameron mentioned, this show is all around care homes, and it's all about changing perceptions. We've got some industry experts with us today, so I just want to introduce them before we kick off. We'd like to welcome Adam James and York Woodford-Smith.
Adam James, Springup PR: I'll jump in and introduce myself first. Thanks, Tobi, and thanks very much, Cameron. I'm Adam James of Springup PR, and in a nutshell we use proven PR and marketing methods to help care operators and care homes get more enquiries and fill beds.
York Woodford-Smith, Five on a Bike: I'm York Woodford-Smith, and I run a company called Five on a Bike. You can ask me about the name later. I've been working with care homes for about six or seven years now, making films to help with the marketing and sales processes within care homes. I've been producing films for about 15 years, I'm formally trained in television production, and I really enjoy working in care homes. Working with residents is one of my favourite things, just finding out what their story is.
Why video matters now
Tobi: Awesome. Before I jump into the questions, I just want to spend some time setting the scene. For about eight weeks straight, whenever we turned on the news or opened the newspaper, there were stories about care homes, ranging from rising care home deaths to not enough PPE. It's probably the most coverage care homes have ever received, but it was 100% negative. It's probably fair to say, unfortunately, that the general public's perception of care homes is not a good one, with some thinking care homes are not a safe place for their loved ones. But all of us know that's not true, and all of us have been actively involved in running confidence-building campaigns for care homes.
York, I want to start with you before we go into the campaigns. You specialise in video. Why is it important that care home owners and operators start thinking about video now?
[2:43]
York: I think they should have been thinking about video a long time ago, but it can feel like a complicated undertaking. In the business world, photography is an accepted thing, whereas video feels more complicated and potentially higher risk. But thinking about it now is really important, because people can't come and visit. As we understand it, the best way to sell your home and get people to come and live in it is to show them what it's like, and that's really difficult to do at the moment. So having a couple of different formats of video will really help you through that process.
One group I worked with did some research, and I think this is generally accepted across the care home industry. When someone is researching a care home for a loved one, and it's normally a family member rather than the person who's actually moving in, they might look at eight to 15 care homes in their local area and then choose maybe three to five to visit. I think now they'll choose one or two, maybe just one. So the competition to be the care home they come and visit is even tougher than before, and all the material that builds their confidence to come for a visit in the first place is really important.
You need to focus on how you can show people the home without them having to come and see it, so they get a sense of the space, what it's like and what the strengths are. You can write as much text on a website as you like, but a video shows them what it's like. It gives a feeling, it's emotive, and that's the biggest thing video has over text or photos. You can create emotion, you can show people enjoying the environment, and footage of the environment feels more genuine than a photo. I think there's an understood perception that photos can be manipulated quite strongly, and video doesn't have that same perception. So having a range of content for your potential customers, or their families, to engage with will increase the likelihood of you getting on that list of places they visit, because people are worried about visiting care homes, which, if you read the newspapers, you can understand.
[5:21]
The two videos every home needs
Tobi: Just staying on that for a bit, you mentioned a range of videos. Let's say someone listening now understands that now is the time to start using video. What are the different types of video they can be using for their home?
York: There are a couple of things. At Five on a Bike, we think the strongest video is an emotive film with the resident at the heart of it. Your residents are the best advocates of your home, followed by the family members. I must have interviewed 50 or 60 residents in various care homes, and across the board they really enjoy the process. They like the attention of a camera crew spending a day with them, and we make sure we keep it on their terms, approaching each person individually. So the strongest thing is basically a testimonial from one of your customers saying, this is what it's like here, and they'll be honest about it as well. We've sat and done interviews with residents where they've told us the good, the bad and the ugly. Maybe you don't address that in your main marketing film, but it's good to give them that outlet. So there's an emotive case study piece, which is really strong.
Then, given the environment at the moment, you need some practical content. As someone looking around for a care home, I just want to see what it looks like. I want to see the gardens, the reception area, how the reception leads into the dining room, how big the dining room is, what the staff look like, what the people who live there look like, how wide the hallways are. Very practical tour videos are really important. One client we're working with together, Tobi, we're making practical tour videos for, because people can't come and see, and they don't want a random person in the home walking around with an iPad showing people things. They want to do it in a controlled way.
So there are two main things. There's a practical tour to show what's here, the facilities, a hair salon or whatever it is you have in your home, shown in a clean and honest way. And then there's an emotive video, which is more about the story of the person. When we make these emotive films, it's probably 80% about the person and 20% them saying it's great to live here, because people connect with people. We've had examples with care home groups where people have said, I would never have considered that brand, it just doesn't sit with me, but I watched the video of the resident and wanted to meet them, and then they've gone into the home, met them and joined the home. I'd love to be able to replicate that in data, but unfortunately in care homes the data process isn't necessarily in place in the way you need. But hearing from my clients that that's how it works is really powerful, and the sales people in the team say, can we have more video? People talk about it when they come to visit. They say, we saw the video, that was great, can we meet this person?
So you've got those two simple bits of content: a practical tour and an emotive case study.
[9:00]
Positive stories for the local media
Tobi: Fantastic, and we're going to touch on case studies a bit later. Adam, I want to come to you as well. With the way the media have been bashing care homes, it's fair to say care homes need to be proactive with the positive stories they put out. During this period, can you share any stories care homes are doing to combat the negative media out there?
Adam: I loved everything we were talking about with video. To answer your question, Tobi: right now, journalists in the regional media, which is the target media for any single care home because that's where their audiences are, are absolutely longing to hear positive stories from care homes, in a way they never have before. Right now is the time for you as a care home to make the local BBC, the local ITV, your local newspaper and the local BBC radio journalists your friends. They are dying to hear the positive stories coming out of your care homes.
Let me give you some numbers. I wrote this out the other day. Nationally, the care sector has taken a big hit, for reasons we're all familiar with. The care sector has gone through a miserable and horrible time, and COVID has hit it dreadfully. To be honest, at the height of COVID, I completely understand why any member of the public would think twice about sending their loved one to a care home, and care home owners will tell you this, because COVID did factually hit care homes in a way that was unpleasant and awful. That's how the national media has covered it. I'm a former journalist, so I can understand why the national media would tell those stories. But looking at it from another perspective, as I said, right now local journalists are dying to hear the positive stories, and there are many, many of them about positive care coming from care homes.
It's perfectly reasonable and proper for every single care home in the UK to secure at least 10 pieces of positive media exposure per home per year. Do the numbers. We've got 17,000 care homes in the UK, and every single one of them, let me repeat, should be getting at least 10 pieces of positive media exposure in the local media per year. That comes to 680,000 pieces of positive media exposure for care homes over the course of a year. When you think about it in that way, the power of the regional media to promote good news stories, and let's remember the regional media is the most trusted media in the UK, more so than the national media, the power of care homes as a collective to promote good care stories is absolutely huge.
[12:21]
Back to your question about positive stories. Anything around providing good care during lockdown is a story your local journalists want to hear about right now. That might be how you celebrate birthdays during lockdown, how you celebrated VE Day during lockdown, how you continue to provide physically stimulating activities when you can't have people coming into your home, stories of residents communicating with their families in a way that's COVID-appropriate, and how you're enabling families to visit residents. For example, one operator we're working with is building summer houses for family members to come and visit their relatives, so they don't have to actually go into the care home, and that's all COVID-appropriate.
Then your staff. Let me be clear here. As Tobi said right from the start, care homes have never been in the news in such a negative way. At the same time, never before has the public had such massive empathy and sympathy for every single care worker in the UK. Healthcare workers, but care workers included, are for the first time in history being seen as heroes. They have been doing amazing work, and there are many, many examples of dedicated care. So you can celebrate your care workers, what they do and how they've provided care, and you'll get a great reaction from the media and from the public.
On Facebook, for example, if you're promoting those stories of your great care, use it as a way to make sure tens of thousands of people per month are hearing about your good-quality care. Not a few people, not a few hundred: reach those big numbers. So that, in a nutshell, is how I'd answer that question.
[14:52]
Molly's story
Tobi: Absolutely, and I want to touch back on that, because it comes back to the individual, whether it's newspaper stories or video. York and I have a joint client who've done an awesome job. Cameron, if it's OK, can you link their video in the show notes? They've done an awesome job with a story around a care home, and York led on that video. York, do you want to give an example of the concept of what we did there?
York: This was probably the beginning of March. No, a bit later than that. We couldn't go to the home, and one of the most difficult things with recording interviews is building a human connection and getting people to open up. Anyone can go in and ask a list of 10 questions, but the real art form is helping people feel comfortable, come out of their shell and forget that there's a camera crew with you and lights and things like that. Over a long time I got used to using different techniques to help people relax on camera, so having to do this over Zoom was a really interesting additional challenge.
We interviewed a resident, a lady called Molly. Have a watch of the video in the show notes. We talked to her and to her daughter, and we just asked what's been going on and what's been happening. The film is two and a half minutes long, and it's about what happened during lockdown. It's really interesting, because there's an elephant in the room if you don't talk about it, especially if your home has been affected and you don't give a nod to what's happened. The further away we move from the crisis point, the less relevant this will necessarily be, but I think a lot of organisations will be worried about how they find the balance in the message, to say that mostly everything is fine, because in most organisations there will be some people who've passed away. You've really got to think about how you manage that message and how you pay respect to the people who've suffered.
But ultimately we need to talk about the hundreds of thousands of people who haven't been affected and who've actually had a better quality of life being in a care home, because they haven't been on their own. They've had people to communicate with. Over the last couple of weeks I've been to a few care homes and interviewed people, and they've said, I'm just really happy I was here. If I hadn't been here, I'd have been locked in my house on my own, and at least here I get to see people and I get food brought to me. It's not exactly what I want, but it's so much better than being on my own.
[18:04]
I really worry about my grandad. He's 97, he's been on his own for three months, and while he's still able to look after himself, it must be really difficult to be completely isolated like that and not be able to have anybody visit.
Molly picked up how to use Zoom and FaceTime really quickly. It's been quite surprising across the different places I've been how quickly people you'd expect not to be able to use this technology have just taken to it. I was speaking to a lady yesterday whose mother is 103, and she said that on a video call her mum was trying to adjust her collar for her, because it feels so real. So even though it's not exactly what you want, the connection is about 80% of the way there. There's another chap I talked to, and I asked if he was excited to see his daughter soon. He said, I've been talking to her every day on Zoom, so I'm not really that fussed if she comes and visits. We'll just wait until it's completely safe. So this technology does get us most of the way to that human connection, although I think there's still a little bit missing for some people. I've found running my business quite difficult over Zoom calls, so my team have come back. Luckily we've got a big office, so we can separate everybody and we're doing shift patterns, but spending time with people is important for me and my team. I've slightly lost track of what the question was, Tobi.
Tobi: It was all about what the story was, and you covered that. It's about Molly, a resident in a care home, addressing that we've lost loads of people across the world, but she's having fun, she's smiling, she's dancing, and the video shows it. It also has a little testimonial from her daughter, and that's lovely to see. It really does help address concerns.
On addressing concerns, I'm a big fan of addressing them directly. Some of the preconceptions people have out there are: is there enough PPE? Imagery, whether it's on Facebook or video, showing people in the correct PPE makes a huge difference. Also, what's the visiting process? Things are changing so quickly, and I don't know whether people are allowed to visit care homes at the moment, but it's still good to know you can do Zoom calls. And then there are issues around isolation, and having visuals of people doing activities really does make a difference. It's about showing families that you've got adequate PPE and they're in great hands. There are loads of positive stories to combat this, in whatever form you can.
[21:01]
The future of care homes
Tobi: I'm conscious of time. It feels like we've only just got started, so I'll probably have to have you both back again. Adam, what are your thoughts on the future of care homes? How do you think COVID-19 will change how care homes are run, how people consume content and how they communicate?
Adam: Great question. I can only speak from our side, because the care is obviously down to the care home, and we're all here talking about PR, marketing and engagement. I loved hearing what York was talking about, and I took some notes. One thing that struck me is that having the full camera crew in with all the flashy gear is a great thing for residents as well. They're on camera, experiencing something that's probably quite unique, and in all likelihood they've not had a full camera crew in before. So it's a special day for them. They'll remember it, and the families will probably remember it too. As well as the power of the video York's been talking about, there's an added element: you're treating a particular resident in a special way. So from a care point of view there's that added element as well, which I just wanted to throw in.
York: I'd like to pick up on that point. Through the COVID process, everything you do is suddenly blown up in front of you. It's been quite an emotional time. You look at these people who do extremely valuable jobs in society, and then PR and marketing sit slightly outside of that, and I've had a slight, I wouldn't say crisis of identity, but you ask yourself how valuable what we do is and how we can help. Last week I went to a care home and sat down with a carer whose husband was extremely vulnerable, so she stayed at the care home for four weeks. Listening to her tell the story, she had that moment where she could almost get it off her chest. It was a really beautiful moment, where she was thinking, somebody's listening to me, somebody wants to hear my story. It was really powerful.
[23:55]
Is video worth the investment?
Tobi: Just a quick one on that, York. A lot of people listening will think, video sounds great, but it's a big investment. What was the purpose of these videos? Is there a clear objective your client had in telling these stories about people? Is it to win new business, to reassure families, to build the brand? What's the core goal?
York: We're going to every single site in the group. It's Sunrise Senior Living, and we're going around all the different sites to create a film for each individual site, as part of a huge PR campaign they're doing called Celebrate Care Homes. They want to make it industry-wide. They've set the foundation for this campaign, and they want to push it out, talk to the whole industry and get the whole industry on board with the message that we should be celebrating care homes, the residents, the staff and the families, as one big cohesive unit, and that everybody in the industry needs to get behind it.
So the real objective of the videos is to help reassure people that it's not what you've read in the national newspapers. If all you did was read the Daily Mail and The Sun, and even the BBC, which we sometimes feel should be more objective than it is, but we won't get into that, you'd have a really negative perception, and it's about trying to combat that story. And yes, it works on a local level and it works for residents.
In the grand scheme of things, as far as I'm concerned, it's not very expensive. It's maybe an investment of a couple of thousand pounds to create something that will last a long time. I was on a pre-production video call with a site we worked with five years ago, where we'd made a story about a resident, and I asked how that was doing. She said it still really works for them now. Five years later, the video is still on their website, and people still mention it on the phone, saying that video of Alan was amazing. So they spent two thousand pounds on that and it's lasted five years, working over and over again. The same goes for the tours. They're not particularly expensive in the grand scheme of things, and they last a long time. So part of it is addressing the idea that video is a long-term investment. You spend a couple of thousand pounds on an individual video, but it will last you at least 12 months, if not two years, and even if you do a huge refurb of your home, you can just do a couple of little updates to the video and fill in some gaps.
So their objective was that it's part of this overall campaign to help the care home industry combat the negative story. And I guess that's part of what we're all doing: trying to show people and help them understand that it's not like what you read in the papers.
[27:04]
One tip each
Tobi: I'm going to put you on the spot quickly for a final thought. Adam, what's one tip you'd give a care home operator right now? If they're going to action one thing, what should it be?
Adam: I'd say make it your goal to be showcased on your local regional BBC. This ties in with video, because essentially York goes in and does a video, which, as York mentioned, will promote your home. My advice for every single operator listening is that within the next six weeks they should be pitching their strongest story to the local regional BBC or ITV, and the BBC tends to be better, and making sure they get a positive news story about their care home on the BBC regional news. Then you can use that video on your website or for promotional purposes. You might have to be careful with the copyright, but there are ways around that. So that would be my one tip, because, as I said from the beginning, right now the local media are longing to hear positive stories from care homes. Let me add one more thing: the care operators doing that will find they become the care home operator the local BBC calls when they want to know about care homes.
Tobi: Awesome. And York, what would your one tip be for someone to take one action off the back of this video?
York: Even if you haven't got the budget for professional video, start doing your own videos. Start letting your staff and your residents talk, get your camera phone out, interview a resident and just ask them what it's been like. It's quite simple to put this stuff together. Put a one-minute video on Facebook, and that stuff is really powerful. We've had this whole shift where user-generated content has suddenly become a completely acceptable form of content, and it's really strong. You see national adverts from banks and insurance companies made up of webcam videos and footage shot on people's phones. A lot of it is pretending to be user-generated content when it's not really, but user-generated content has this real raw honesty about it.
One of the reasons people use professional video is that if the quality is so bad you can't understand the message, you have a problem. But technology is so good now that you can start producing content yourself, and the local media will pick it up. If you send a one-minute video of your residents saying what a lovely time they've been having, they're probably more likely to pick that up than if we went in and shot a professional film. So you've just got to be brave, create content and send it out to people. Put it on your Facebook page, share it into local Facebook groups, and let your residents, your staff and the families tell your story.
[30:30]
Tobi: Awesome. If I can add one tip as well, mine would be to double down on testimonials during this period. When people have concerns, a story from a family will go a long way. Whether it's written testimonials, video testimonials from residents, or inviting families onto a Zoom call and recording it, it doesn't have to be the glossiest thing. It's actually quite authentic, and it really does go a long way in changing perceptions of the care sector and building up the confidence of the general public. So that's all from me. Over to you, Cameron.
Cameron: I think it's been a really good episode. Video is such a big subject, and it's not really been covered much in the care sector before, so we'll definitely have to have the guys back on to explore it more, because there's a lot we didn't get to today. It just shows how undiscovered the topic is and how much you can dial into video. From a marketing side, there are other reasons as well: we can track better metrics and get more data from videos than we can from images. Also, every single person on this podcast does video for their business, so we're not telling you to do something we don't do ourselves. We're 100% invested in it. Check out everyone's videos: York's got great tips on video, Adam's got his marketing and PR videos, and obviously we've got our Tea with Tobi and Whiteboard Weekly series. I'll leave it there. I'll add everything we discussed to the show notes, and we'll see you all in the next Tea with Tobi.
Tobi: See you, guys. Thanks so much.
Podcast Sponsor
The Access Group is the largest supplier of software to social care providers in the UK. Over 8000 care settings use Access’ integrated, comprehensive systems to deliver safer, higher quality care with greater efficiency. Access’ systems for care providers range from scheduling and rostering, eMAR and medication management, electronic care records, care delivery, risk and governance, recruitment and much more.
