In this episode:
There’s no shortage of media articles declaring a “recruitment crisis” in the UK care sector and predicting a deficit of #carers to meet the needs of an ageing population. However, in our experience care recruitment doesn’t need to be as difficult as it’s made out to be!
Therefore, on this week’s #TeaWithTobi we have none other than the master of care recruitment Neil Eastwood to discuss tactics to help your #homecare or #carehome business prosper whilst others fall into the crisis!
This isn’t your run of the mill appearance from Neil either, as we ask questions that get Neil to share practical measures you can take to streamline your recruitment process in line with changing behaviour amongst job hunters!
Find Neil here:
neil@carefriends.co.uk
https://carefriends.co.uk/
http://www.savingsocialcare.com/
https://stickypeople.co.uk/
https://www.linkedin.com/in/neil-eastwood-334344/
Resources mentioned:
Saving Social Care – Neil Eastwood
Nudge – Richard H Thaler
Hooked – Nir Eyal & Ryan Hoover
Slack Tool: https://slack.com/intl/en-gb/
Special thanks to our season sponsor everyLIFE Technologies:
everyLIFE Technologies are creators of the PASSsystem, a digital care planning solution that is proven to improve business efficiency, help you stay compliant, allow you to evidence accountability and provide the best quality care. Visit their website for more information: https://www.everylifetechnologies.com/
Listen to the audio version on your favourite platform:
► Apple Podcasts
► Spotify
Download your free care growth Ebook:
Home Care Ebook
Care Home Ebook
[00:00]
Neil Eastwood: You're just writing an advert to appeal to as many people as possible, and that speaks to no one. So I think what we need to do is look at the demographic groups and address their needs, press their buttons.
Cameron: Hi, I'm Cameron from Smooth Digital [Smooth Digital, now Prosperwell], and welcome to Tea with Tobi, the show where we ask and answer the questions playing on the minds of care sector business leaders. This week's episode is sponsored by everyLIFE Technologies, and we'd also like to thank Google for allowing us to use their lovely podcasting studio. So, as always, we're going to kick off the show with a few words from our marketing strategy director, Tobi Alli-Usman.
Tobi Alli-Usman: Thanks for the intro. For those of you who are new to the show, let me give you some background. At Smooth Digital, our ultimate aim is to help care home businesses and home care businesses maximise their ability to provide the very best care in the community. In order to do that they need to grow, but we know there are a number of challenges that care business leaders face. So we want this to be the place where we discuss the challenges and give solutions, and you can walk away with some tangible tips to implement in your business right away. On that note, I'd like to introduce our guest for today, Neil Eastwood. Neil, before we get into the meat of the podcast, could you give us a little background about yourself and your expertise?
Meet Neil
Neil: Yes, sure. I've been looking at this particular area, the recruitment and retention of care staff, for maybe 12 years. That was triggered by working in a home care provider. I was a director of a home care provider with 10,000 staff. They had massive problems, and I thought I should do something about it. Fast forward about 10 years or so, and a couple of years ago I wrote Saving Social Care, because I had so much data and so many tips and ideas from around the world, and I put that in the book. And most recently, I'm working on a start-up called CareFriends, which is brilliant.
Using marketing techniques to recruit staff
Tobi: So we're going to jump straight in, in true Tea with Tobi fashion. We're the marketing guys for the care sector, and you're the recruitment guy. So the first question for you is: how can care businesses use marketing techniques to recruit staff?
Neil: That's a really good question, and I think you guys have a lot to bring to this. If you look at social care, we've not really had to market too heavily. Certainly, if you look at the future and right now, customer demand is so huge that we don't need to spend a lot of money on marketing and sales. That's created a problem, because we often don't have the skills and experience in-house to use marketing skills.
[03:02]
Many years ago, I saw marketing expertise like yours transfer across to recruitment, and I think that's where we need to be. There are a couple of areas. If I was looking to apply marketing to the recruitment process, I would say the first one is how we sell the job. Classically, we think between 50% and 75% of all the activity in recruitment sourcing is through internet job boards, and the wording is really awful in many cases. It's called big net advertising. Lee Davis in the US, who is a fantastic recruiter, came up with this idea: you're just writing an advert to appeal to as many people as possible, and that speaks to no one. So I think what we need to do is look at the demographic groups and address their needs, press their buttons. That's one area.
The second area, which I think we really could do better on, is the candidate experience. As an applicant, am I getting a good brand experience of that employer? That sets the tone, if I haven't dropped out already, for what my expectations and feelings are about that employer. When I responded, did I hear anything? The danger is that if I apply to you, you're too busy, you don't reply, and I live locally, and the recruitment catchment in home care is about six miles, that's a problem, because now I'm dissing you. So there are two areas there. And you'll have lots of input, I'm sure, in terms of how you can apply the world you're in to some of those cases.
On the latter one, I tell providers: go on your phone, because that's how people are trying to apply now, and apply for your own job. Apply for a care worker job in your organisation. It can be a horrific experience.
Tobi: Yes, and I think the advice about going on their phone is important. A lot of people are trying to recruit using social media, the tool most people use to recruit care staff, and if they went on their phone to apply for a job, they'd probably be met with an application form. The reason that's not the best thing is, let's think about Facebook. People go on Facebook to pass the time, a bit of downtime. They're scrolling through, and if they see an ad for a job and click through to an application form, it's a bit disruptive. Am I really going to be filling in this application form? I've got a CV to upload.
[06:05]
So there's a cleverer way to do that. But you mentioned candidate experience. How can care businesses give a better candidate experience?
Neil: Well, let's pick up on the point you just made. Don't shove it, and it's more likely to be digital now, a seven-page application form in front of people before there's any relationship built up. We certainly see in recruitment that the most successful sources are those using personal connection, where there's some kind of connection with somebody who works for the company, employee referral being a great example, or they've been cared for by the company. There's already some information there. If there's none, and I've applied on a job board, and I'm looking within a 50-mile radius for a job, I have no idea that your care company is any different to any others. It's just another competitive offering for roughly the same money, and then I'm hit with seven pages. I am not finishing that form.
In fact, we did a test where there was a seven-page form, and of those people who completed page one, and that was a massively reduced number by the way, take a deep breath, let's start on the journey, less than 10% ever completed it. So yes, the CQC, if you're in England, asks for a complete and full employment history and a complete and full application form, but the timing of that is the issue. Do not shove it in someone's face. People don't have the time.
Tobi: It's all about bite-sized information. Think about the few things we need to ask. Most of what's on the CV doesn't tell us anything about the suitability of that person to be a care worker, I would even say. So streamline it down in terms of the fields you include: name, email address, telephone number, and for a home care business, the postcode and confirmation that they drive. If it's a care home, maybe you don't need those. Then request a call back, and get the rest of the information on the telephone interview. That way, when someone first comes across the ad, they're not overwhelmed, thinking, OK, I need to put time aside to sit down and fill in this application.
I was even remembering my younger brother when he graduated. I asked how things were going, and he said, I'm planning to apply for jobs on Thursday at this time. Some people think that way: I'm going to apply for jobs at this time, and that's them. So you want to be the ad that, when someone's scrolling through, they'll do it then, because it's quick: just put the information in here and move on.
Reducing staff turnover
Tobi: Next question for you. Let's say a company has a good flow of leads coming through in terms of recruitment.
[09:06]
They're actually hiring staff, so recruitment is good, but retention is poor. What can a care business do to reduce staff turnover?
Neil: OK, so you said recruitment was good. Actually, recruitment isn't good, because that's a large driver of why people are leaving straight away. What you mean by good is good volume, and good volume is often bad news, because it bogs you down processing lots of people who are half-hearted, or, to your brother's example, I'm going to apply for more than one job in that hour. So suddenly there's a glut of me out there, and for all the care providers it's like blood in the water. They're going for you, and you're going to have a choice of different interviews, being offered probably the same money. So how do I choose?
This is one of those things where we have a brand problem compared to, say, the NHS. If one of those jobs was an NHS job, and I work there, I tell my friends and my mum, and she thinks, oh, you're an angel. Whereas if you say, I work for ABC Care: really? So there's a major problem in that recruitment space. Where are we sourcing those people from in the first place? We know that if they have a history of family care, caring for a loved one, or they were referred by an employee, or there's some kind of connection, the drop-off is much less. So part of the retention problem you described is actually caused by the pool of candidates you happened to choose in the first place. That's point one.
The second point is: what's the experience in the very early period of employment? I split retention into three areas, and they get progressively easier. The first one is: I give you a job offer, and you still haven't come in. I have to do a police check, a DBS, I have to do references. You might go back to your previous employer and they panic and make a counter-offer, or you have to give notice. During that period, when you're not there, there's no relationship with me, and it's a massive problem. I've made you a job offer, I'm planning my rosters knowing Tobi's coming, and suddenly Tobi's not coming, so now I have to go to the agency. That's one chunk, and there are interventions we can do to fix things there.
The second chunk is from your very first minute walking in the door: induction, training and the first 90 days' survival. You walk in on day one and decide, is anybody smiling? We know that about 20% of people who leave on day one said nobody smiled at them or made them feel welcome. I was told to sit in that chair and mind my own business, because they're all too busy.
[12:03]
Often we sell really well. You have a really good recruiter, they're account managing you, and then they hand you over to operations, and this is like a disaster, because operations are not focused on Tobi's first day. They're focused on all the other things they have to do. Oh, we've got an inspection, oh my goodness. So I think that 90-day survival rate is very important, particularly the first week or the first day. After the first 90 days, things get a lot better. People who survive 90 days feel the job is right for them, and then you're looking at long-term interventions, like feeling appreciated, because we can't just give them as much money as we would like to.
Active and passive job seekers
Tobi: Touching on your point about quantity, I'm guessing you think it's about quality.
Neil: Definitely.
Tobi: So how can care businesses get more quality recruitment leads?
Neil: I would split applicants into two groups. First, active job seekers, who are being chased by everybody else. Because care staff work very locally, unless they've moved, my question is: why are you on the market? Your employer had better be pretty awful, otherwise you've walked away from your residents, the people you support. Or were you fired? I'm never going to find that out from a reference. So there's a problem in the system of people moving around, job hoppers, and a question about the quality of active job seekers generally. You do get volume, although that's reducing now, and volume means you're bogged down processing people, trying to call back people who never answer the phone, and no-shows for interview. So that's active job seekers, and you need to treat them a certain way.
Then there are passive job seekers, which is much more exciting. That's about ten times as big a group, if I'm thinking of a six-mile radius around a care home or a home care territory. We need to go and find those people in the community and say, Tobi, you shouldn't be doing the job you're doing, you'd make a wonderful support worker. Reaching them is the challenge. After that, if you've been selected for your values by somebody, for example an employee, happy days, because you're not being chased by any other employer. No one else knows about you. You feel connected. You have a friend in the company already.
So I think we need to think about the sources. Active job seekers are in a certain mentality: they're likely to be promiscuous about which job they take, and you'll see drop-outs before and after starting, at an early stage. Then there are passive job seekers, much harder to find, but when you find them, oh my goodness, they're wonderful. So as a recruiter you have the mix of the two groups. And where I'm seeing the world moving is much more towards the passive side, because there are many people in the community who haven't thought about social care, who are busy doing something they don't enjoy, or are retirees, and we need to tell them.
[15:04]
It's our duty to go and tell them.
Tobi: And that's pretty much the campaigns we run. A lot of people favour the job boards. I don't know if I've said this on the podcast before, but recruitment managers would prefer to respond to those people because it's less work. They already know about the sector, and they know, for example, whether you get paid between visits. Whereas passive people need to be excited about the sector. They need to be told about what it entails, told about the company, the role and the career journey. It's a lot of work to do that.
Neil: I can imagine. But I think to solve the crisis, instead of recycling the same batch of support workers, we need to go out into the world and bring in more people. As the recruitment market tightens up and demand keeps growing, you have no option. And we think it's easy. I've been there, placing those ads on a Friday night and thinking, inboxes full on Monday, happy days. That was the easy bit. The hard bit is trying to bring any of those people in for an interview and then keep them. So where do you want your effort to be? I'd rather be picking people. That means long-term marketing campaigns and outreach. It means not getting so bogged down by all those half-hearted applications that you never leave the office, never build a relationship with the local hospice supporters group, never engage in the community, and let your employee referral scheme fall away. You don't push it, and you don't encourage your staff to be out there. If you think about it, most care providers have lots of staff, and those people could be out there recruiting for you.
Cameron: That's the perfect point for us to take a little break, so remember your question. We'll be right back, everyone.
Tobi: "We really need private paying clients in our care business, but we don't understand the world of digital marketing. What should we do?" That's a question we get a lot from businesses in the community. So we've put together an ebook called The Care Growth Blueprint, which is a step-by-step guide to the marketing steps you need to put in place to attract private paying clients into your business. Download the ebook, the link should be in the description below, and enjoy the rest of the show.
How to split your recruitment time
Cameron: Welcome back, everyone, and we'll jump right back in with Tobi.
Tobi: Lovely. I'm really enjoying this, and I love the way it's practical and quantifiable. My next question for you: there are care business leaders listening right now, and they've got so many things to think about. They're trying to run the business and make sure staff are all right,
[18:04]
processes, systems, policies. When it comes to recruitment, if there was a pie, what percentage of time do you think should be split between job boards, referrals, social media, paid ads and offline activity?
Neil: Time-wise, I would say my priority would be to make sure my employee referral scheme is humming. That won't take me much time, maybe a quarter or a fifth of my time, just to make sure it's fun and engaging, and that's the world we're getting into with CareFriends, making that more efficient. You really want a bedrock of about a quarter to a third, more if you can, but that's probably the limit, of your new starters coming from employee referrals. That would be a priority, because that's the bedrock of high quality, and I think any other prioritisation will bring in applicants or starters who are more likely to leave, meaning back we go again to do more recruitment. So maybe 20% on that.
In terms of job boards, there would be some work every so often to refresh my adverts. I would be on job boards, because that's where active job seekers largely are. We'll come on to Facebook and social media, and you'll have a view on this, but I would be very targeted with my ads, and I would have tightened up my application process so that I'm not wasting time. So I'd be quite cautious there, and I'd probably be doing 25%. Those two things would probably take up about half my time.
Then social media, which from my point of view is still Facebook, and I think this is really exciting, because we're still at the very early stages of capitalising on it. You might need some external help to measure and A/B test, testing different images and response mechanisms and so on. It's not expensive to use Facebook for recruitment advertising, and I think the results are improving all the time, as well as the referral connection, so that would take another chunk of my time.
If you're talking about outdoor and more traditional forms of advertising, we know that in terms of high performers, that's only going to bring you about 9% of your high performers, roughly the same as job boards. But I would be out there, placing ads or posters
[21:04]
somewhere, and I would be talking to people in the local community. We've identified community sources where you're more likely to find people who are suited to this kind of work. So I would combine my offline advertising with simply talking to people and building relationships and networks. That would probably be the rest.
Finding staff in the community
Tobi: And with the community sources, what kind of places should they be investing their time in, out in the community?
Neil: Recent research I've done, which took me five years but we recently published, identified a massive chunk, about 30%, of all high performers. That's a manager picking, say, Tobi as my top performer. What was the experience that made him first join? Before paid care, the winner by a large margin is that you have a brother or sister with a disability that you cared for. So I need to go into the community and find people like you, and the places I would find you would be: I'd be sponsoring or partnering with my local hospice, because I'd get my staff along to the candlelit walks and connect with the supporters group, who have all cared for a loved one who has died. So they've got time, they know what care is, and they're probably thinking, you know what, I could do that job. So I would be looking at them, and at the carers' centres, the informal carers. How can we help those people, so they help you back? That's one. And then there are many other places: anyone volunteering, people who work in charity shops, who are giving their time to people. So lots of places.
Tobi: On a previous point you made, about time spent on social, just to break that down a little bit. When it comes to Facebook specifically, there are three main strategies. One is your organic reach. The strategy used to be to build up your Facebook following, so that when you put out posts your followers see them. But Facebook changed their algorithm, we think because they want to make a bit more money, so now only a fraction of people see organic posts, even though they're following you. They want you to start putting some money behind your posts, and that's called boosted posts. That's the second way to do it. Boosted posts are good because you can reach a wide range of people, but marketers tend to frown on them because there's no science behind it. It's just going out to anyone and everyone. The next level, which is a bit more specific, is paid ads. That's where you can target people based on their job role, so you can reach people who are in retail,
[24:02]
a particular age, a particular demographic, or interested in particular things, and then you can do some really clever A/B testing. It would be good to talk about that another time.
CareFriends
Tobi: Now I'm going to move the conversation on a little bit and talk more generally about business. You're back in the tech world with CareFriends. What's CareFriends?
Neil: CareFriends is an employee referral app for social care, obviously. What it does is remove the friction from employee referral, which is a manual process, and incentivise it using gamification. A point would typically be a pound. So if I share the job with you, I might get a point for it. If you expressed interest and filled in the tiny application form, which is exactly what you described, just contact details and a postcode, I might get two points, two pounds. If you came for interview, I might get ten, and if you're hired, boom, I get a big bonus, and maybe after three months I get more. So the idea is to maximise the efficiency and effectiveness of an employee referral scheme. That's what CareFriends is.
Tobi: And I know you'll probably get those people who are really into loyalty schemes, who are literally going to go out and tell their friends, do this, refer this, refer this. So where did that come from? What made you think about it?
Neil: Last year, I felt, of course, campaigns have to be a big part of it, but I felt the highest quality was coming from the employees themselves, and we know this from research. Employee referral is the number one source of staff quality, not volume, around the world, always. So I got thinking, can we up those numbers? And then I realised, hang on a minute, why are we doing bits of paper and a tatty old poster in the care home, when we can make it a digital, interesting and painless journey?
Business tools and books
Tobi: So, wearing your business hat, and I just wanted to have this conversation on this forum: are there any tools you use that make your life easier, that you couldn't live without in business?
Neil: By far the number one for me would be Slack.
Tobi: So what is Slack, for the people who don't know?
Neil: Slack is like a better version of email, I guess. It's a board that delivers conversations, so you can immediately see them, and people can be tagged in, involved or not involved. I can check back, so if I've been in a meeting, like today, I'll check Slack afterwards and I can see what the team are talking about. Whereas email is
[27:04]
kind of a batch process. I'm getting an email, or someone's copying me in, and I have to tell this person, and it's so disjointed. Slack is like a digital conversation. It's pretty cool.
Tobi: Awesome, we're going to link that in the show notes as well. We want to talk about the wider business conversation too. Is there a business book you would recommend? It doesn't have to be one that's helped you.
Neil: Oh, yes. Most recently I'm in the start-up world, and there are several really excellent start-up books. Because we're looking at gamification and changing behaviour, one is Hooked. Nudge is another really interesting one, which is about changing behaviour at scale, changing the public's behaviour. So I'm in that world of psychology at the moment, and what we need to do to make CareFriends a success is enable employers to tell their staff to download the app, because we don't do that ourselves, and explain why they'd want to. So that's really cool to me right now.
Tobi: Are there any gems you've learned that you can talk about, in terms of the influence?
Neil: Yes, really. In terms of incentives, often employers, and I, might present something in the context of what's important to us. But it helps you to put yourself in the mind of the employee: why should I bother doing this thing? And it really focuses you on not saying too much, because people can't cope with all of that. Single messages, and what's in it for me, why should I bother. And everyone's so busy, so we have to be really tight with how we say things, what we say and what the ask is. That gives me discipline, so I keep going back to that book.
Tobi: So Hooked is on Amazon, and we'll put the link there.
Neil: Yes, Hooked by Nir Eyal.
Tobi: Thank you. Neil, I would love to have you on again, but in the interest of time, where can people find you if they want to reach out?
Neil: Anyone can email me at neil@carefriends.co.uk. CareFriends.co.uk is the main website. I have a website for the book, Saving Social Care, and one for Sticky People, but CareFriends is the focus at the moment, so give me a call or drop me a line.
Cameron: Perfect. Thanks again, Neil, that was really good. Tobi even managed to mention Nando's,
[30:06]
so I think that means they owe us a Nando's. Thanks, everyone, for watching. As always, everything will be in the show notes: all of Neil's handles on social media and his contact information, as well as the great resources he's given us. And we will see you next time.
Tobi: See you next week.
Podcast Sponsor
Podcast Sponsor:
everyLIFE Technologies are creators of the PASSsystem, a digital care planning solution that is proven to improve business efficiency, help you stay compliant, allow you to evidence accountability and provide the best quality care.
