Why Isn't My Care Business Marketing Plan Working?

‍

‍

There are many moving pieces to the care marketing machine.

Whether you are doing traditional methods like leaflets or digital marketing or a combination, the ultimate goal for all methods is the same. The goal is to get potential clients to reach out to you enquiring for your services.

There are three trends we have been seeing in the care industry as to why marketing efforts are failing.

‍

1) You’re Not Tracking What’s Working (or What Isn’t)

‍

One of the biggest marketing failures in the care industry is poor attribution. If you’re spending on leaflets, radio, local magazines, or even Google Ads but don’t know which channel is driving actual calls, you’re flying blind.

Sure, you might notice a few more calls after a campaign, but without accurate tracking (like call tracking numbers, landing page analytics, or CRM integration), you’re guessing. And guessing doesn’t scale.

👉 Fix it: Implement proper attribution tools. That means UTM codes, unique phone numbers for each campaign, and tracking form fills or live chats. Marketing only works when you measure what matters.

‍

2) Your Website Looks Good But It’s Not Built to Convert

‍

You can have the prettiest website in the world, but if it isn’t guiding users to take action, it’s not doing its job.

We see this often in care: sites that are polished but passive. They inform, but they don’t convert.

Here are a few critical landing page mistakes we see:

• Too many links – Users get distracted and leave before enquiring.
  
  
• Slow load times – Especially on mobile. That’s a conversion killer.
  
  
• Unclear value proposition – What makes you different from the five other providers they just Googled?
  
  
• Multiple CTAs – Confusing the user with “Learn More”, “Contact Us”, “Subscribe” and “Book a Call” all at once.
  
  

👉 Fix it: Design landing pages with a more narrow and focussed goal: to generate enquiries. Keep it focused, fast, and persuasive. (We cover this in depth in our 10 Landing Page Commandments.)

‍

‍

‍

3) Lack Of Staff Training

‍

Here’s the hard truth: even with great marketing, it can all fall apart at the first human interaction.

We’ve seen care homes get high-intent enquiries from families in urgent need only for the lead to be mishandled. Calls go unanswered. Staff sound robotic. Questions get dodged instead of resolved. That’s a lost opportunity.

Your front-of-house team is your best salesperson. But most aren’t trained in enquiry conversion.

👉 Fix it: Train your staff on how to handle inbound leads with empathy, urgency, and clarity. We offer lead handling workshops tailored for care providers, designed to turn more calls into admissions.

Why not have your team 100% ready to convert leads? 

We help care businesses like yours generate consistent, qualified enquiries and convert them. If you’d like a fresh pair of eyes on your marketing strategy, book a free discovery session with our team.

Let’s make sure your marketing is working for you, not against you.

‍

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

‍

1. How can I tell which marketing channel is actually generating enquiries?
Use call tracking numbers, Google Analytics with UTM codes, and CRM tagging to attribute each enquiry to its source. These tools allow you to see which campaigns, channels, or ads are delivering real ROI and which aren’t.

2. What’s the most effective type of marketing for care businesses?
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, but if you’re targeting private/self-funding clients, Google Ads is often the most direct and effective route. We help our clients run campaigns that target people actively searching for terms like “care home near me” or “live-in carer for mum”. In our 10+ years of experience, this consistently drives high-quality enquiries.

3. We’ve got a great-looking website! So why aren’t people getting in touch?
Design alone doesn’t drive results. Your website needs to:

• Clearly communicate what makes you different (your USP)
• Load fast (especially on mobile)
• Build credibility
• Guide users towards one clear action — typically an enquiry form or phone call
  If it’s just “pretty”, but not persuasive, it won’t convert.
  

4. How quickly should our team respond to new enquiries?
Ideally, within 5 minutes. That’s the window where families are most engaged. After 30 minutes, conversion rates start to drop sharply. We know that in care this isn’t always easy — but faster, warmer responses almost always mean more move-ins.

5. What’s lead handling training and do we really need it?
Lead handling training equips your team to turn calls and enquiries into real clients. It covers everything from tone of voice and empathy, to objection handling and follow-up processes. Even the best marketing will fall flat if the first conversation doesn’t build confidence and trust.

6. Can I get a review of my current marketing setup?
Absolutely. If you’re investing in marketing and want to increase your private enquiries especially through PPC we’d be happy to review what you’re doing and explore where improvements can be made. Just get in touch to schedule a no-pressure discovery call.